Jonathan Oppenheim
@postquantum.bsky.social
📤 1719
📥 277
📝 206
Quantum mechanic with a lot of ontological baggage.
https://www.ucl.ac.uk/oppenheim/
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
John Preskill
13 days ago
Every December since 2017, I've delivered a keynote at Q2B Silicon Valley, commenting on recent progress in quantum computing. Here is what I said this time. It's been a good year for quantum.
quantumfrontiers.com/2025/12/26/q...
loading . . .
Quantum computing in the second quantum century
On December 10, I gave a keynote address at the Q2B 2025 Conference in Silicon Valley. This is a transcript of my remarks. The slides I presented are here. The first century We are nearing the end …
https://quantumfrontiers.com/2025/12/26/quantum-computing-in-the-second-quantum-century/
1
27
4
🤦 This is why the public doesn’t trust scientists...
add a skeleton here at some point
25 days ago
0
5
0
OpenAI leadership are promoting a paper in Physics Letters B where GPT-5 proposed the main idea — possibly the first peer-reviewed paper where an LLM generated the core contribution. One small problem: GPT-5's idea tests the wrong thing. My technical comment:
scirate.com/arxiv/2512.0...
1/
about 1 month ago
5
43
19
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
Dulwich Quantum Computing
about 1 month ago
"A single person claims to have authored 113 academic papers on artificial intelligence this year, 89 of which will be presented this week at one of the world’s leading conference on AI and machine learning,"
www.theguardian.com/technology/2...
loading . . .
Artificial intelligence research has a slop problem, academics say: ‘It’s a mess’
AI research in question as author claims to have written over 100 papers on AI that one expert calls a ‘disaster’
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/dec/06/ai-research-papers
1
10
3
We are in the era of Science Slop! (and it's exciting):
open.substack.com/pub/superpos...
loading . . .
We are in the era of Science Slop
(and it's exciting)
https://open.substack.com/pub/superposer/p/we-are-in-the-era-of-science-slop?utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=web
about 1 month ago
1
13
4
Great article on quadratic gravity, and why researchers are attracted to it (it's renormalisable). The pure gravity action of postquantum-classical gravity is the same us that of quadratic gravity but with a different interpretation, and it doesn't suffer from ghosts!
arxiv.org/abs/2402.17844
⚛️🧪
add a skeleton here at some point
about 2 months ago
0
7
2
The
#QIP2026
list of accepted papers is out!
qip2026.lu.lv/programme/ac...
highlighting some of the important papers in quantum computing in the past year. This is a fantastic slice from a very rich landscape. Congratulations to the authors! ⚛️🧪
loading . . .
Accepted papers
https://qip2026.lu.lv/programme/accepted-papers/
about 2 months ago
0
8
3
A recent
@nature.com
article claims that classical (unquantised) gravity produces entanglement. We show that their model does not produce entanglement. Even if the model produced entanglement, it would be mediated by the quantised matter interaction, and not gravity.
scirate.com/arxiv/2511.0...
🧪⚛️
loading . . .
Classical gravity cannot mediate entanglement
In Nature, 646, 813 (2025), Aziz and Howl claim that classical (unquantised) gravity produces entanglement. We show that their model does not produce entanglement. Even if the model produced entanglem...
https://scirate.com/arxiv/2511.07348
about 2 months ago
1
17
5
We'll enjoy it while it lasts!
add a skeleton here at some point
2 months ago
0
5
0
Another day, another arxiv paper claiming that classical gravity can produce entanglement. Last week's Nature paper continues to cause confusion. But classical fields can't create entanglement *even if* they directly couple two masses. Comment added at
superposer.substack.com/p/no-classic...
2 months ago
1
10
2
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
As promised... No, classical spacetime can’t produce entanglement. I can create entanglement by turning a knob on a laser, but the knob isn't mediating entanglement. Is the knob "producing" the entanglement? This week's Nature paper is causing confusion!
superposer.substack.com/p/no-classic...
🧪⚛️
add a skeleton here at some point
3 months ago
1
21
8
As promised... No, classical spacetime can’t produce entanglement. I can create entanglement by turning a knob on a laser, but the knob isn't mediating entanglement. Is the knob "producing" the entanglement? This week's Nature paper is causing confusion!
superposer.substack.com/p/no-classic...
🧪⚛️
add a skeleton here at some point
3 months ago
1
21
8
No they do not. I'll try to write something up in the next few days....
add a skeleton here at some point
3 months ago
3
18
8
What if the measurement problem isn't about explaining how the classical world emerges from the quantum world... ...but about what happens when quantum systems interact with something that's already classical? Turns out, the collapse postulate + Born rule emerge!
scirate.com/arxiv/2510.0...
🧪⚛️🧵1/5
loading . . .
A one-world interpretation of quantum mechanics
The measurement problem is the issue of explaining how the objective classical world emerges from a quantum one. Here we take a different approach. We assume that there is an objective classical syste...
https://scirate.com/arxiv/2510.09149
3 months ago
3
30
5
Maite Arcos's PhD results are hitting the arxiv! A resource theory of gambling, and a paper on adversarial thermodynamics are out today. Gambling provides an operational way to quantify who has more information. And it can be extended into the quantum domain!🧵🧪⚛️ 1/
3 months ago
1
24
0
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
John Preskill
4 months ago
6,100 neutral-atom qubits trapped in a grid by lasers
@caltech.edu
... is a lot.
www.caltech.edu/about/news/c...
loading . . .
Caltech Team Sets Record with 6,100-Qubit Array
The neutral-atom platform shows promise for scaling up quantum computers.
https://www.caltech.edu/about/news/caltech-team-sets-record-with-6100-qubit-array
3
73
13
They sure take electromagnetism seriously in
@quantumaephraim.bsky.social
's lab!
4 months ago
1
9
0
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
FQxI
4 months ago
In a recent Substack post, FQxI's Jonathan Oppenheim discusses how far
#LLMS
have progressed.
@postquantum.bsky.social
says "their answers often look very convincing on the surface until you go through them more carefully". DISCUSS:
forums.fqxi.org/d/4283-how-g...
0
5
2
The CERN whitepaper, on testing the quantum nature of gravity, has even more co-authors and is now available on the arxiv,
scirate.com/arxiv/2509.0...
. Check it out! 🧪⚛️
loading . . .
A Spin-Based Pathway to Testing the Quantum Nature of Gravity
A key open problem in physics is the correct way to combine gravity (described by general relativity) with everything else (described by quantum mechanics). This problem suggests that general relativi...
https://scirate.com/arxiv/2509.01586
4 months ago
1
19
3
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
Nature
5 months ago
There is one fundamental phenomenon that quantum physics can't explain: gravity
go.nature.com/45v70f1
loading . . .
Is gravity quantum? Experiments could finally probe one of physics’ biggest questions
Physicists are developing laboratory tests to give insight into the true nature of gravity.
https://go.nature.com/45v70f1
1
58
14
I'm at the African Institute for Mathematical Science Ghana this week for a quantum hackathon. Which is apparently called a Quantathon! Excited to interact with great students and researchers from across Africa. Live feed at
t.co/J8UzPKc6Vx
& schedule at
qtedu.aims.edu.gh
. Public lecture on Friday.
6 months ago
0
12
0
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
David Rankin
6 months ago
FACT THREAD on New Interstellar Object
#A11pl3Z
This story unfolded pretty fast yesterday for a few reasons. The object was discovered on July 1st UTC by the Asteroid Terrestrial-impact Last Alert System, or ATLAS team. A
#NASA
funded survey at the University of Hawaii.
atlas.fallingstar.com
🔭🧪
8
325
157
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
Chris Lintott
6 months ago
!!!!! Waking up to the news that we might have found an interstellar object passing through our Solar System - only the third ever seen. Looks convincing based on the orbit.
add a skeleton here at some point
19
696
221
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
Dan Garisto
7 months ago
NEW: NSF will be kicked out of their building. Announcement will be made tomorrow by HUD Sec. and Governor of VA. HUD will take over the NSF building over the next two years. NSF staffer: "There is no planning for NSF, no identified future location, appropriation for a new building or a move."
109
2806
2025
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
Katie Mack
7 months ago
Just click on this:
skyviewer.app/explorer
#RubinTelescope
loading . . .
Explorer | Skyviewer
https://skyviewer.app/explorer
38
528
179
Sad news, Ray was both a a really kind man and a great scientist.
add a skeleton here at some point
7 months ago
0
11
0
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
Quanta Magazine
7 months ago
What if gravity isn’t a pull from mass, but a push from entropy?
@georgemusser.com
reports on the latest version of an old idea.
www.quantamagazine.org/is-gravity-j...
loading . . .
9
129
27
Is there a way to stem the endless cavalcade of cats, birds, and sunsets flooding my feed? No matter how many times I hit 'show less like this,' they keep coming. Anyone else drowning in cats?
@rose.bsky.team
@jay.bsky.team
@support.bsky.team
7 months ago
1
1
0
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
Oz Amram
7 months ago
Scientists for Palestine is holding a school on quantum physics Palestinian students in Jordan in July, but they need donations to make it happen! 🇵🇸
www.scientists4palestine.org/palestinian-...
www.gofundme.com/f/support-pa...
loading . . .
Palestinian Advanced Physics School 2025 - Scientists For Palestine
The Palestinian Advanced Physics School 2025 (PAPS) will be held in-person at the University of Jordan between 26th — 31st July 2025. Additional students will join remotely from Gaza. The school is ai...
https://www.scientists4palestine.org/palestinian-advanced-physics-school-2025/
0
4
3
On Sunday, I'll be at the Cheltenham Science Festival, with Andrew Pontzen, Hiranya Peiris and Cham Ghag, discussing whether the phenomena we attribute to dark matter, could be explained by stochastic fluctuations in spacetime. Come say hello!
www.cheltenhamfestivals.org/events/quant...
🧪⚛️
loading . . .
Quantum Dark Matter | Cheltenham Festivals
Astronomers have been amassing evidence for “dark matter” in space – far more mass than can be seen directly. Yet, despite intensive efforts, there is no
https://www.cheltenhamfestivals.org/events/quantum-dark-matter
7 months ago
1
10
2
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
Carl T. Bergstrom
8 months ago
Elon Musk wanted to buy Wikipedia so that he could determine our society’s collective view of truth. He couldn’t, so he created grok. Do not let these machines be arbiters of truth. It is abundantly clear that they are being used to push absurd far-right conspiracies.
loading . . .
Musk’s AI bot Grok blames ‘programming error’ for its Holocaust denial
Grok doubted 6 million death toll, days after peddling conspiracy theory of ‘white genocide’ in South Africa
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/may/18/musks-ai-bot-grok-blames-its-holocaust-scepticism-on-programming-error
25
820
273
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
Timothy Gowers
8 months ago
I wonder what the "Why don't you go and protest in China?" brigade will make of this news.
www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-cle...
loading . . .
Analysis: Clean energy just put China’s CO2 emissions into reverse for first time - Carbon Brief
For the first time, the growth in China’s clean power generation has caused the nation’s carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions to fall despite rapid power demand growth.
https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-clean-energy-just-put-chinas-co2-emissions-into-reverse-for-first-time/
1
23
4
I'm at the Quantum Symposium at
@uniofnottingham.bsky.social
and they have a working Lego interferometer!
9 months ago
1
13
1
If we want fewer psychopaths in charge, we should start with ranked-choice voting. It’s about as complicated as picking pizza toppings with friends.
9 months ago
0
8
0
The final session, on "Table-top quantum experiments for gravity" with Flaminia Giacomini, Richard Howl and Sougato Bose, closes out the QISS conference in Vienna
vienna2025.qiss.fr/index.html
. The recorded talks and subsequent discussion should appear online in the coming days. 🧪⚛️
9 months ago
0
10
2
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
Mark M. Wilde
9 months ago
This past week, I received a second stop work order on one of my grants. This now means that we can no longer spend on *two* of my major grants. Several of my group members will now graduate earlier than expected, I am looking into being a consultant for the summer, and students will do internships
3
54
12
As someone who loves paradoxes and these two in particular, I'll be very disappointed if they're actually the same...
add a skeleton here at some point
9 months ago
1
7
0
I've been asking various AI models math questions. I'm sure they'll one day be impressive mathematicians, but wow, they're insufferable! Confidently wrong, dopamine-addicted, and desperate for likes. I wrote up my experience here:
open.substack.com/pub/superpos...
loading . . .
Insufferable mathematicians
AI mathematicians will one day be impressive, but for now, they're confidently wrong, dopamine-addicted, and desperate for likes.
https://open.substack.com/pub/superposer/p/insufferable-mathematicians?r=165zf&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=false
9 months ago
2
9
1
Tim Gowers
@wtgowers.bsky.social
claimed that Grok solved the Dubnový Blázen problem as an April Fools Day joke. Now Google thinks the Dubnový Blázen problem is a real problem in graph theory (it's Czech for "April Fools").
9 months ago
0
33
6
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
Dulwich Quantum Computing
9 months ago
"Despite the hype, it’s been surprisingly challenging to find quantum algorithms that outperform classical ones. In this episode, Ewin Tang discusses her pioneering work in “dequantizing” quantum algorithms — and what it means for the future of quantum computing."
add a skeleton here at some point
0
16
3
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
Simon Lewis
10 months ago
#TakedownTesla
demo in London. Important to stand up to the xenophobic anti-science class war Musk and Trump are waging.
1
15
3
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
The Author, Séamas O'Reilly
10 months ago
Not to be a wide-eyed naïf about such things but... am I right in thinking that they levelled an entire building to get to one guy and *that* is not controversial to anyone in the American media or political class, only that this information was recklessly shared in an unsecured chat?
1647
34893
9455
This is part of DESI's recently released map of our universe. Each snowflake in this blizzard is a galaxy. Not sure if it's terrifying or comforting, but it's definitely jawdropping! More videos at
noirlab.edu/public/video...
🌌⚛️ 🧪
loading . . .
10 months ago
2
80
26
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
DESI Survey
10 months ago
JUST RELEASED: DESI DR1 & BAO RESULTS FROM DR2🌌
1
56
24
It wasn't long ago that
@hossenfelder.bsky.social
famously critical of new physics theories, highlighted the postquantum theory of gravity as one of the top five breakthroughs of 2024. But is the honeymoon over? ⚛️ 🧪1/
10 months ago
8
20
2
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
John Preskill
10 months ago
Jason Alicea opines that topological quantum computing is entering the POST-Q era. High quality topological qubits are not likely to arise suddenly; rather (like other qubits) they will improve gradually over an extended period. Jason explains here.
quantumfrontiers.com/2025/03/05/w...
loading . . .
What does it mean to create a topological qubit?
I’ve worked on topological quantum computation, one of Alexei Kitaev’s brilliant innovations, for around 15 years now. It’s hard to find a more beautiful physics problem, combining spectacula…
https://quantumfrontiers.com/2025/03/05/what-does-it-mean-to-create-a-topological-qubit/
1
42
9
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
Simon Evans
11 months ago
NEW: Official advisers CCC say UK shld cut emissions 87% by 2040 ⚖️Net cost of net-zero 73% less than thought 💷Total cost to 2050 = £108bn (~£4bn/yr, 0.2% GDP) 🏡🚗H’hold energy/fuel bills to fall £1,400 🔌Electrification is key THREAD + charts
www.carbonbrief.org/...
1/10
16
540
348
Not surprising, but massive nonetheless. In case the dangers of closed LLM models controlled by oligarchs is not clear enough.
uk.pcmag.com/ai/156828/gr...
loading . . .
Grok Was Briefly Instructed Not to Say Musk, Trump Spread Misinformation on X
The lead engineer at xAI blames an employee who 'hasn’t fully absorbed xAI's culture yet' for the glitch. Grok 3 now says Elon Musk is the biggest spreader of misinformation on X.
https://uk.pcmag.com/ai/156828/grok-was-briefly-instructed-not-to-say-musk-trump-spread-misinformation-on-x
11 months ago
0
11
0
Quantum computing is an exciting field and most experts believe we'll build a useful device within decades. But quantum-hype from tech companies do the field a massive disservice. To cut through the bullshit I'd recommend following... ⚛️ 🧪 🧵 1/
11 months ago
4
100
29
reposted by
Jonathan Oppenheim
Nigel Warburton
11 months ago
Thomas Piketty on the state we are in
www.lemonde.fr/blog/piketty...
loading . . .
Trump, national-capitalism at bay
For anyone in doubt, Donald Trump has at least made things clear: the right exists and it speaks loudly. As has often been the case in the past, it takes the form of a mixture of violent nationalism, ...
https://www.lemonde.fr/blog/piketty/2025/02/18/trump-national-capitalism-at-bay/
0
32
20
Load more
feeds!
log in