Tobias Forsnacke
@forsno.bsky.social
đ€ 77
đ„ 92
đ 423
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Michael Weiss
8 days ago
Europeans worry Trumpâs TruthSocial post means heâs walking away from Ukraine. My latest on what that isnât necessarily a bad outcome:
macspaunday.substack.com/p/in-praise-...
loading . . .
In Praise of Trumpy Boredom
Published exclusively on Substack
https://macspaunday.substack.com/p/in-praise-of-trumpy-boredom
6
109
35
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Wiseman
12 days ago
Jag fick möjligheten att bjuda Tove Lifvendahl pÄ kaffe och en rejÀl pratstund om min resa frÄn försvarsbloggare till förbandschef, samt de utmaningar och problem som sÄvÀl Försvarsmakten som Sverige stÄr inför med den rÄdande omvÀrldsutvecklingen.
www.svd.se/a/Ey6P5a/sto...
loading . . .
âStörsta hotet Ă€r vĂ„r oförmĂ„ga att förstĂ„â | SvD Ledare
LEDARE. Han var en anonym och tongivande försvarsdebattör. Nu leder Carl Bergqvist utbildningen av svenska stridspiloter och vÀssar Sveriges förmÄga att bedriva luftstrid.
https://www.svd.se/a/Ey6P5a/storsta-hotet-ar-var-oformaga-att-forsta
1
40
6
Not sure Iâm buying the âNATO failed hardâ interpretation that seems to dominate this site. Three QRAs intercepted the Russian MiGs and thereâs a lot of escalation ladder to climb before getting to the use of force. Isnât this just back to Cold War everyday reality?
14 days ago
0
0
0
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
ChrisO_wiki
15 days ago
1/ While today's incursion into Estonian airspace by three Russian MIG-31s is the most serious such incident in 30 years, it's not the first time that it's happened. It also highlights a strategic vulnerability for Estonia: it does not have a fully agreed border with Russia. âŹïž
11
232
74
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
François Heisbourg
21 days ago
Quite possibly. But why would China do this?
add a skeleton here at some point
1
20
1
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Keir Giles
22 days ago
A curious phenomenon in the swirling commentary: people seeing comparisons between Charlie Kirk and Horst Wessel and/or his murder and the Reichstag fire, and then appearing more concerned that the American right may not know history than that it may know it very well and see it as a role model.
add a skeleton here at some point
6
41
10
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Helene von Bismarck
23 days ago
Rationality is vastly overrated.
5
66
10
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Oliver Alexander
28 days ago
No no, you donât understand. Trump was a white hat pedophile.
loading . . .
12
196
26
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Keir Giles
about 1 month ago
âCoalition of the willingâ, âsecurity guaranteesâ and now a âbuffer zoneâ: the meaningless European pantomime continues while Russia contentedly proceeds with its murderous campaign.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=-PYB...
loading . . .
Ukrainian DMZ is âunfeasibleâ and only benefits Putin | Keir Giles
YouTube video by Times Radio
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-PYBMwF8Crg
8
75
29
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Timothy Snyder
about 1 month ago
"Nothing that happened in medieval eastern Europe bound future states to make war against each other a thousand years later" My latest essay: "The myths that made Putinâs war"
www.ft.com/content/9731...
loading . . .
The myths that made Putinâs war
The Alaska summit exposed the flawed history and personal vanity that fuel the conflict with Ukraine, argues Timothy Snyder
https://www.ft.com/content/97312cf6-127d-411e-9690-a22e4396e2d0?accessToken=zwAGPQ5361G4kdOXMSz2En1BHtOWkKIuQ5bi0A.MEQCIG9J_xzmmsmkElSk6eXb5HZpXpObc_jUH2Iw2FGsSmBGAiBmU6FdeTsA0G3Hs2nB9SNPFEiPVyp6d0a3q6plsIyTUg&sharetype=gift&token=b02c8847-9561-484f-9d39-a540c4a89cef
37
1303
464
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Mark Urban
about 1 month ago
Is the international rules based order dead? And what even is it? My latest video for The Times
youtu.be/4T6oSqazmlw?...
loading . . .
Is the Old World Order Dead?
YouTube video by Times Originals
https://youtu.be/4T6oSqazmlw?si=NRqOxdlXL4j8SU5F
0
12
5
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Anders Puck Nielsen
about 1 month ago
Lindsey Graham is instrumental in normalizing Trump's Putin-friendly line and keeping Ukraine's supporters in the Republican Party passive.
add a skeleton here at some point
14
175
26
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
François Heisbourg
about 1 month ago
Yes, we have much catching up to do. Thankfully the US, with its European-sized debt, its abysmal budget deficit, its French style demographics, its above-average inflation, its 19th century protectionnism, has so much to teach us.
add a skeleton here at some point
2
41
9
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
François Heisbourg
about 1 month ago
Double-unsmart as Orwell could have put it. The US undercutting the Five Eyes, one of its most effective tools of imperial influence projection since World War2, must be the wet dream of every one of its enemies or rivals
add a skeleton here at some point
3
44
13
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Keir Giles
about 2 months ago
Another busy morning of media reality checks. Still a vast gap between (a) excitable reporting based on comments from European leaders who are humouring Trump instead of saying "this will never work", and (b) what anybody who knows Russia and has been paying attention knows is likely to happen.
6
51
14
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Steve Rosenberg
about 2 months ago
Following the meeting of Trump, Zelensky & European leaders one Russian paper says âZelensky & Europeans poured sugar into the gas tank of the Alaska negotiations. They sweet-talked Trump.â Another paper: âDetails of Ukraine settlement are more & more confusing.â
#ReadingRussia
loading . . .
Russian paper: "Zelensky & Europeans pour sugar into gas tank of the Alaska talks"
YouTube video by Steve Rosenberg
https://youtu.be/Norw6T-jFDk
17
211
59
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Anna Wieslander
about 2 months ago
Ahead of meetings in DC today, the road ahead looks incrasingly dangerous. Trump puts pressure on Ukraine to push through his appeasement policy toward Russia. Putin still refuses any true concessions. Europe is running behind trying to handle the fire but there is too much smoke.
2
16
5
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Steve Rosenberg
about 2 months ago
âTrump has adopted Russiaâs position,â writes one Russian paper today. âHe will present his peace ultimatum to Zelensky. And thereâs no doubt itâs an ultimatum.â My review of todayâs Russian papers.
#ReadingRussia
loading . . .
"Trump has adopted Russia's position" writes one Russian paper today.
YouTube video by Steve Rosenberg
https://youtu.be/0t22bJDgnsE
25
360
169
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Steve Rosenberg
about 2 months ago
Russian media are hailing the Alaska summit as a big win for Moscow: âą âa tactical victory for Russian diplomacyâ âą âhuge diplomatic victory for Vladimir Putinâ âą âTrump perceived Russiaâs interests as legitimate.â
loading . . .
What the Russian papers are saying about the Alaska summit
YouTube video by Steve Rosenberg
https://youtu.be/_WAVXyIgTDg
44
342
166
youtu.be/c3JFO2fRels?...
loading . . .
Going beyond the "M" in "Drone Warfare"
YouTube video by The Chieftain
https://youtu.be/c3JFO2fRels?si=iNY3tQ6WAYwvF2Sx
about 2 months ago
0
0
0
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
WarTranslated (Dmitri)
about 2 months ago
Former Trump adviser John Bolton believes Putin achieved nearly all his goals at the summit, while Trump got only promises of more meetings. Bolton notes Putin avoided sanctions, faced no ceasefire demands, and that Trump appeared very tired after the talks.
loading . . .
17
502
134
âYou cannot scale a zoo of disparate systems in a long war; modern war demands solutions that can be scaled.â
add a skeleton here at some point
about 2 months ago
0
0
0
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Sam Greene
about 2 months ago
"The risk is not that Europe overreaches, but that it undershoots. Europe will never have all the resources it needs to assure itself of victory. Failing to go to diplomatic war with the army it has, however, assures it of defeat." My two cents ahead of Anchorage for
@cepa.org
loading . . .
Unmoored in Anchorage: Europeâs Dangerous Game
Europe has done everything possible to align itself with the US administration. That has avoided difficult decisions, but comes at a risk.
https://cepa.org/article/unmoored-in-anchorage-europes-dangerous-game/
21
169
52
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Randall Munroe
about 2 months ago
Where Babies Come From
xkcd.com/3127/
36
3073
462
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Franzén
about 2 months ago
Good. If the US chooses Russia rather than Europe and Ukraine, the EU need to sanction Russia into economic oblivion.
add a skeleton here at some point
1
4
1
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Justin Bronk
2 months ago
Just published via RUSI... I suspect this one may generate some strong opinions but I think it's an important set of factors for military planners especially in the Land domain to engage with: NATO Should Not Replace Traditional Firepower with âDronesâ
www.rusi.org/explore-our-...
loading . . .
NATO Should Not Replace Traditional Firepower with âDronesâ
Over-reliance on uncrewed aerial systems or âdronesâ is leading to significant problems for the Armed Forces of Ukraine, and is not something Western militaries should attempt to replicate
https://www.rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/rusi-defence-systems/nato-should-not-replace-traditional-firepower-drones
12
220
77
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Ulrike Franke
2 months ago
The 2% (3,5%, 5% etc) are not contributions to the NATO budget!
add a skeleton here at some point
5
89
10
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
François Heisbourg
2 months ago
If this were a make-believe world, this promise would be perfectly understandable. But having made this absurd promise, what happens to the EU if or when Trump Trump decides that he's playing for keeps?
add a skeleton here at some point
3
10
2
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Alberto Rizzi
2 months ago
My take on the US-EU trade deal in this
@ecfr.eu
policy alert: - EU preferred an unequal deal rather than retaliating to maybe get a better one - Some economic silver linings don't cancel the political capitulation - EU needs credible retribution to prevent further US demands
ecfr.eu/article/scot...
loading . . .
Scot-free: What Europeans should take from Trumpâs trade deal
Ursula von der Leyen and Donald Trump have announced a 15% tariff on most EU goods exported to the US. The compromise has avoided a trade war for nowâbut Europeans need to safeguard the dealâsâŠ
https://ecfr.eu/article/scot-free-what-europeans-should-take-from-trumps-trade-deal/
2
15
9
SÄ var det dags att avsluta SvD-prenumerationen i vredesmod igen. FÄr se hur lÀnge jag klarar mig utan morgontidning den hÀr gÄngen (det börjar bli nÄgot av en tradition).
2 months ago
0
0
0
Givet artikelförfattarna sĂ„ borde det hĂ€r bara vara att göra. NĂ€r förvĂ€ntas ĂB komma med militĂ€ra rĂ„d för den nya budgetramen?
kkrva.se/fight-the-de...
loading . . .
Fight the deep â en analys avseende foÌrmaÌgegap och konsekvenser
Denna artikel riktar sig till chefer och beslutsfattare med ansvar för försvarsplanering och förmÄgeutveckling inom Försvarsmakten. Syftet Àr att belysa de förmÄgegap som för nÀrvarande försvÄrar vÄr ...
https://kkrva.se/fight-the-deep-en-analys-avseende-formagegap-och-konsekvenser/
3 months ago
1
0
0
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Jeremy Cliffe
3 months ago
Faced with Trump's 30% tariff, the EU urgently needs a comprehensive map of its retaliatory options; ranging across goods, services, IP, digital, finance & people-to-people measures (including their cost to Europe). Fortunately, we
@ecfr.eu
have already published that map:
ecfr.eu/publication/...
loading . . .
Brussels holdâem: European cards against Trumpian coercion
Faced with an aggressive United States, Europe has more leverage than it realises. Across trade, technology, infrastructure, finance and people-to-people relations it has ways of retaliatingâŠ
https://ecfr.eu/publication/brussels-holdem-european-cards-against-trumpian-coercion/
16
136
47
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Renee DiResta
3 months ago
The alignment ppl must be dying inside
add a skeleton here at some point
2
66
8
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Bruno Tertrais
3 months ago
(1/2) Nuclear deterrence: 30 years after the Chequers Declaration, a major strategic announcement will take place today as London and Paris will state they are opening the possibility to "coordinate" their nuclear deterrents and that they now protect Europe against "extreme threats".
2
44
27
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
The Economist
3 months ago
Our analysis of what it has cost both sides
loading . . .
Russiaâs summer Ukraine offensive looks like its deadliest yet
Our analysis of what it has cost both sides
https://econ.st/46wJPTE
2
17
7
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Fabian Hoffmann
3 months ago
In any case, what these numbers show is that a denial strategy related to Russia's conventional ballistic missile arsenal is not feasible. Even ignoring operational factors, such as fire unit deployment and suboptimal interceptor allocation, the math doesn't check out. 6/7
1
113
15
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Phillips OBrien
3 months ago
Hello All, latest in @TheAtlantic . Once again, the US has shown that it fails to understand air power. Trump's intervention in the Israel-Iran air war was showy and seems to have accomplished little.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archiv...
loading . . .
The Problem With Having the Mightiest Air Force in History
American leaders refuse to learn from allies and overestimate the benefits of showy tactical attacks.
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2025/07/trump-iran-air-strikes/683428/?gift=BQHDq1p24LRO8cUUEyLQ6xjgX9LTp4pLeixFVIVpsTo
57
1126
297
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Fabian Hoffmann
3 months ago
The best course is to enable Ukraine to return the punishment tenfold. That should also be Europeâs response to Russiaâs missile buildup: embrace a conventional countervalue posture and aim thousands of cruise and ballistic missiles at every high-value target west of Kazan. 2/2
7
199
42
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Michael Kofman
3 months ago
Some things here may be dated but I still found it useful. If you follow drone use in Ukraine then you likely know a lot of whatâs in this piece. Yet the perspective is nonetheless helpful.
warontherocks.com/2025/06/i-fo...
loading . . .
I Fought in Ukraine and Hereâs Why FPV Drones Kind of Suck â War on the Rocks
https://warontherocks.com/2025/06/i-fought-in-ukraine-and-heres-why-fpv-drones-kind-of-suck/
4
121
26
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Phillips OBrien
3 months ago
So the US air campaign against Iran seems to have gone like this. 1) Trump does not want to get involved 2) he is told that Israel is having lots of success 3) he becomes desperate to join to he can be seen to âkick assâ 4) He bombs Iran one night
9
448
107
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Alexander Clarkson
3 months ago
Sometimes the right strategic thing for Europeans to do is just watch events unfold on their phone while sitting in a nice cafe 1000 miles away from all the chaos
16
275
50
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Alexander Clarkson
3 months ago
A good thread in many ways. But backers of the JCPOA also need to face how it was never coupled with mechanisms to contain the further expansion of Iranian support for Hezbollah and other proxies which fueled Israeli frustration in ways that helped lead to this mess now
add a skeleton here at some point
9
79
21
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Randall Munroe
4 months ago
Exoplanet System
xkcd.com/3103/
32
2554
387
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Anna Wieslander
4 months ago
"Mr. Trump has spoken with Mr. Putin regularly, as recently as Saturday, when he said that the Russian leader had called him to wish him a âHappy Birthdayâ and spent more time discussing the Iranian-Israeli conflict than the war he started."
www.nytimes.com/2025/06/16/w...
loading . . .
Trump Renews Embrace of Putin Amid Ongoing Rift With Allies
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/16/world/canada/trump-g7-russia-ukraine.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare
0
10
5
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Franzén
4 months ago
Well, well, well.
2
6
2
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Mark Urban
4 months ago
I've blogged about how the Israeli air force has reshaped the Middle East and what others might learn from them
markurban.substack.com/p/israels-sl...
loading . . .
Israel's Sledgehammer
How their air force re-shapes the Middle East
https://markurban.substack.com/p/israels-sledgehammer
12
59
18
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Fabian Hoffmann
4 months ago
Hi all, I published my latest newsletter earlier today, providing an initial assessment of Operation Rising Lion. The operational picture is still unfolding, but there are already some takeaways to highlight. Access the post here:
missilematters.substack.com/p/operation-...
Summary below. 1/5
loading . . .
Operation Rising Lion: Initial Assessment and Implications
Israeli air superiority, the failures of Iranian grand strategy, and strategic-level targeting
https://missilematters.substack.com/p/operation-rising-lion-initial-assessment
5
110
30
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Justin Bronk
4 months ago
Notable that many of the F-15s and F-16s in
#IAF
footage - supposedly from last night - are carrying 2000lb GBU-31(V)1 JDAMs. Suggests Israel has established sufficient control of the air to operate non-stealth aircraft directly over Iranian targets without relying on standoff weapons like Rampage
8
81
22
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
Alexander Clarkson
4 months ago
The Axis of Resistance project proved a gargantuan waste of money for Iran that is unable to deter Israel when the chips are down
2
66
20
reposted by
Tobias Forsnacke
H I Sutton
4 months ago
How it started. How itâs going.
5
220
29
Load more
feeds!
log in