loading . . . CHAT CONTROL 2.0 THROUGH THE BACK DOOR β Breyer warns: βThe EU is playing us for fools β now theyβre scanning our texts and banning teens!β Just before a decisive meeting in Brussels, digital rights expert and former Member of the European Parliament Dr. Patrick Breyer is sounding the alarm. Using a βdeceptive sleight of hand,β a mandatory and expanded Chat Control is being pushed through the back door, in a form even more intrusive than the originally rejected plan. The legislative package could be greenlit tomorrow in a closed-door EU working group session.
**βThis is a political deception of the highest order,β warns Breyer. βFollowing loud public protests, several member states including Germany, the Netherlands, Poland, and Austria said βNoβ to indiscriminate Chat Control. Now itβs coming back through the back door β disguised, more dangerous, and more comprehensive than ever. The public is being played for fools.β**
According to Breyer, the new compromise proposal is a Trojan horse containing three poison pills for digital freedom:
**1. MANDATORY CHAT CONTROL β MASKED AS βRISK MITIGATIONβ**
Officially, explicit scanning obligations have been dropped. But a loophole in Article 4 of the new draft obliges providers of e-mail, chat and messenger services like WhatsApp to take βall appropriate risk mitigation measures.β This means they can still be forced to scan all private messages β including on end-to-end encrypted services.
**βThe loophole renders the much-praised removal of detection orders worthless and negates their supposed voluntary nature,β says Breyer. βEven client-side scanning (CSS) on our smartphones could soon become mandatory β the end of secure encryption.β**
**2. TOTAL SURVEILLANCE OF TEXT CHATS: A βDIGITAL WITCH HUNTβ**
The supposedly voluntary βChat Control 2.0β goes far beyond the previously discussed scanning of photos, videos, and links. Now, algorithms and AI can be used to mass-scan the **private chat texts and metadata of all citizens** for suspicious keywords and signals.
**βNo AI can reliably distinguish between a flirt, sarcasm, and criminal βgroomingβ,β explains Breyer. βImagine your phone scanning every conversation with your partner, your daughter, your therapist and leaking it just because the word βloveβ or βmeetβ appears somewhere. This is not child protection β this is a digital witch hunt. The result will be a flood of false positives, placing innocent citizens under general suspicion and exposing masses of private, even intimate, chats and photos to strangers.β** Under the current voluntary βChat Control 1.0β scanning scheme, German federal police (BKA) already warn that around 50% of all reports are criminally irrelevant, equating to tens of thousands of leaked chats per year.
**3. DIGITAL HOUSE ARREST FOR TEENS & THE END OF ANONYMOUS COMMUNICATION**
In the shadow of the Chat Control debate, two other disastrous measures are being pushed through:
* **The End of Anonymous Communication:** To reliably identify minors as required by the text, **every citizen** would have to present their ID or have their face scanned to open an email or messenger account. **βThis is the de facto end of anonymous communication online β a disaster for whistleblowers, journalists, political activists, and people seeking help who rely on the protection of anonymity,β** warns Breyer.
* **βDigital House Arrestβ:** Teens under 16 face a blanket ban from WhatsApp, Instagram, online games, and countless other apps with chat functions. **βDigital isolation instead of education, protection by exclusion instead of empowerment β this is paternalistic, out of touch with reality, and pedagogical nonsense.β**
**URGENT APPEAL: GOVERNMENTS MUST NOW USE THEIR VETO!**
Several EU governmentsβincluding those of Germany, the Netherlands, Poland, Czechia, Luxembourg, Finland, Austria, and Estoniaβhave previously voiced strong opposition to indiscriminate mass scanning.
**βNow, these governments must show some backbone!β** demands Breyer. **βBlock this sham compromise in the Council and demand immediate corrections to save the fundamental rights of all citizens. The EU Parliament has already shown, across party lines, how child protection and digital freedom can be achieved together.β**
Breyer demands the following immediate corrections before any government should agree:
1. **No mandatory chat control through the back door:** Clarify that scans cannot be enforced as βrisk mitigation.β
2. **No AI chat police:** Restrict scanning to known child sexual abuse material (CSAM).
3. **No mass surveillance:** Only allow targeted surveillance of suspects based on a court order.
4. **Preserve the right to anonymity:** The mandatory age verification requirement must be scrapped entirely.
**βThey are selling us security but delivering a total surveillance machine,β Breyer concludes. βThey promise child protection but punish our children and criminalize privacy. This is not a compromise β this is a fraud against the citizen. And no democratic government should make itself an accomplice.β**
* * *
**About Dr. Patrick Breyer:**
Dr. Patrick Breyer is a jurist, digital rights expert, and a former Member of the European Parliament (Pirate Party) until 2024. As a co-negotiator of the Parliamentβs position on the Chat Control regulation (CSAR), he is a leading European critic of indiscriminate mass surveillance. https://www.patrick-breyer.de/en/chat-control-2-0-through-the-back-door-breyer-warns-the-eu-is-playing-us-for-fools-now-theyre-scanning-our-texts-and-banning-teens/
