Proof News
@proofnews.bsky.social
📤 4167
📥 6
📝 54
Data-driven reporting and analysis of the most important questions of our time. proofnews.org
reposted by
Proof News
Julia Angwin
10 months ago
It seems that there is one issue of bipartisan agreement during this week’s Presidential transition: federal support for building more AI data centers. In his final days, Biden directed the gov't to lease federal lands to build AI data centers. And Trump appears to have endorsed the plan.
4
17
5
reposted by
Proof News
Julia Angwin
10 months ago
Also note the careful wording on requiring data center developers to “bring online sufficient clean energy generation resources to match the full electricity needs of their data centers.” That is not the same as being fully powered by clean energy, as
@agordon.me
explains:
youtu.be/jFd0QUOUFUg?...
loading . . .
How AI is Hogging the Electric Grid
YouTube video by Proof News
https://youtu.be/jFd0QUOUFUg?si=ENSiSIIEBYa1v62o
2
48
17
reposted by
Proof News
Julia Angwin
10 months ago
Dr. Shaolei Ren, expert on data center water usage, says AI companies have already exceeded the water usage of the largest beverage companies in the world.
youtu.be/Vqvb3G8hJiI?...
loading . . .
Ingredients: Dr. Shaolei Ren on AI’s extraordinary water consumption
YouTube video by Proof News
https://youtu.be/Vqvb3G8hJiI?si=lN-rPp8nrY8h9UbG
1
66
35
reposted by
Proof News
Julia Angwin
10 months ago
No mention of water conservation in White House EO giving federal lands to AI data centers. Data centers are very thirsty creatures!
www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-roo...
loading . . .
Statement by President Biden on the Executive Order on Advancing U.S. Leadership in Artificial Intelligence Infrastructure | The White House
The United States leads the world at the frontier of artificial intelligence (AI). Cutting-edge AI will have profound implications for national security
https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2025/01/14/statement-by-president-biden-on-the-executive-order-on-advancing-u-s-leadership-in-artificial-intelligence-infrastructure/
19
211
114
You may have heard that having a conversation with ChatGPT is the climate equivalent of pouring out a bottle of water. In fact, that is likely an underestimate. In the 3rd installment in our series on the climate costs of AI, we tackle AI’s unquenchable thirst.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=s67L...
loading . . .
How AI is Guzzling Up the Water Supply
YouTube video by Proof News
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s67L2otHw0I
11 months ago
3
17
13
What is the carbon cost of using an AI bot? The companies stopped disclosing it in 2022. In the latest installment in our series on the climate costs of AI, we estimate a year of ChatGPT use may emit the same amount of CO2 as driving 2 million miles.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=yekA...
loading . . .
How AI is Killing Climate Goals
YouTube video by Proof News
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yekAtc4eT78
12 months ago
2
16
11
reposted by
Proof News
Since 2017, electricity consumption at the biggest AI makers has soared: 186% at Google 186% at Microsoft 367% at Meta The reason: AI.
@agordon.me
examines the electrical costs of AI in the first episode of our YouTube series on the climate impacts of AI.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=jFd0...
loading . . .
How AI is Hogging the Electric Grid
YouTube video by Proof News
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jFd0QUOUFUg
12 months ago
3
47
40
Since 2017, electricity consumption at the biggest AI makers has soared: 186% at Google 186% at Microsoft 367% at Meta The reason: AI.
@agordon.me
examines the electrical costs of AI in the first episode of our YouTube series on the climate impacts of AI.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=jFd0...
loading . . .
How AI is Hogging the Electric Grid
YouTube video by Proof News
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jFd0QUOUFUg
12 months ago
3
47
40
We are thrilled to announce that Proof News is joining Nebula – the independent creator-led video streaming platform. Our video investigations will appear on Nebula as well as on the corporate-owned platforms. Indie newsroom + indie platform = stronger together!
nebula.tv/proofnews
loading . . .
Proof News
You deserve better facts. Proof provides data-driven reporting and analysis of the most important questions of our time.
https://nebula.tv/proofnews
12 months ago
1
7
1
Proof News is an independent nonprofit newsroom. We do rigorous investigations of powerful companies. We have no corporate overlords. We have no ads and no third-party trackers on our site. We are honored DuckDuckGo chose us as one of their annual donations!
spreadprivacy.com/2024-duckduc...
loading . . .
2024 DuckDuckGo Charitable Donations
DuckDuckGo is donating $1.1 million in 2024 to support organizations that share our vision of raising the standard of trust online.
https://spreadprivacy.com/2024-duckduckgo-charitable-donations/
12 months ago
5
4
2
"In the world of AI and misinformation and propaganda circulating online, we must make it very clear why our audiences should trust our piece of information versus another piece,”
@juliaangwin.com
tells Editor & Publisher.
www.editorandpublisher.com/stories/proo...
loading . . .
Proof News: Redefining objectivity in a world of disinformation - Editor and Publisher
Although the daily challenges of reporting and publishing have never been greater, both must continue to evolve. Being a leader of that change is the mission of Julia Angwin and her team at Proof News...
https://www.editorandpublisher.com/stories/proof-news-redefining-objectivity-in-a-world-of-disinformation,252729
about 1 year ago
0
7
3
In our latest AI testing, the leading chatbots were pretty decent at detecting and debunking known vote count misinformation. With one notable – and surprising – exception: ChatGPT.
loading . . .
What’s Up With ChatGPT? The AI chatbot didn’t debunk known election misinformation
Proof News presented examples of debunked election misinformation to five leading consumer facing AI products.
https://www.proofnews.org/whats-up-with-chatgpt-the-ai-chatbot-didnt-debunk-known-election-misinformation/
about 1 year ago
0
5
6
AI models are fluent in many languages - holding out the promise of helping break language barriers. But our latest investigation reveals that the models return a higher rate of inaccurate answers to questions posed in Spanish than identical questions posed in English.
loading . . .
AI Models Falter Answering Election Questions in Spanish
If you ask Google’s AI chatbot, Gemini, about voter fraud in English, it starts off by correctly telling you that such fraud is “incredibly rare,” and gives you a list of topics that are “more product...
https://www.proofnews.org/ai-models-falter-answering-election-questions-in-spanish/
about 1 year ago
1
3
2
reposted by
Proof News
Julia Angwin
about 1 year ago
Google’s Gemini AI has stopped advising people to eat rocks. But other AI models — looking at you OpenAI and Meta — are advising people to lick rocks. The latest
@proofnews.bsky.social
collaboration with creators to test AI in their areas of expertise. 👇🏻
loading . . .
Don’t Ask AI Which Rocks You Can Lick
And other performance issues when it comes to language models and geologyj
https://www.proofnews.org/dont-ask-ai-which-rocks-you-can-lick/
0
11
7
reposted by
Proof News
Center for Democracy & Technology
about 1 year ago
“If a group of people might be disproportionately affected when AI models are making mistakes, that's important for voters to know and for the AI developers to know, [CDT’s @isabelalinzer.bsky.social] said.”
www.proofnews.org/ai...
loading . . .
AI Models Provide Inaccurate Information to Voters with Disabilities
Research from the Center for Democracy and Technology found problems with AI models' responses to over 60% of 77 election-related prompts.
https://www.proofnews.org/ai-models-provide-inaccurate-information-to-voters-with-disabilities/
1
2
2
reposted by
Proof News
Center for Democracy & Technology
about 1 year ago
“AI models are frequently putting out false and inaccurate information that could dissuade voters with disabilities from voting, according to new research from CDT using an AI model comparison tool created by @proofnews.bsky.social.” cc: @eedugdale.bsky.social
www.proofnews.org/ai...
loading . . .
AI Models Provide Inaccurate Information to Voters with Disabilities
Research from the Center for Democracy and Technology found problems with AI models' responses to over 60% of 77 election-related prompts.
https://www.proofnews.org/ai-models-provide-inaccurate-information-to-voters-with-disabilities/
1
2
2
AI Models are producing inaccurate information about voting options for people with disabilities more than 60% of the time, according to a new study using Proof’s AI testing platform.
www.proofnews.org/ai-models-pr...
loading . . .
AI Models Provide Inaccurate Information to Voters with Disabilities
Research from the Center for Democracy and Technology found problems with AI models' responses to over 60% of 77 election-related prompts.
https://www.proofnews.org/ai-models-provide-inaccurate-information-to-voters-with-disabilities/
about 1 year ago
0
2
2
Top AI models generated misleading info about Kamala Harris and Donald Trump 30% of the time. From incorrect answers about eligibility to false claims about Medicare cuts, find out how these technologies fail us.
www.proofnews.org/ai-models-st...
loading . . .
AI Models Generate Misinformation about Presidential Candidates
Posed questions about Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump, top AI models generated misleading information 30 percent of the time.
https://www.proofnews.org/ai-models-struggle-to-get-the-facts-straight-about-kamala-harris-2/
about 1 year ago
0
10
4
Internal communications show Nvidia raced to build a competitor to OpenAI’s Sora, and concerned employees in the process by resorting to downloading masses of copyrighted YouTube videos.Â
www.proofnews.org/nvidia-scrap...
loading . . .
Nvidia Scrapes YouTube, Eyes Netflix, Discovery to Train New Video Model
Despite employee concerns, management encouraged massive scraping of copyrighted content, documents show
https://www.proofnews.org/nvidia-scrapes-youtube-eyes-netflix-discovery-to-train-new-video-model/
over 1 year ago
0
1
0
How accurately do leading AI models respond to questions about Black history? @MrCrim3 gives them a "C."
www.proofnews.org/tiktok-teach...
loading . . .
TikTok Teacher Ernest Crim III Gives AI Models a “C” In Black History
How accurately do leading AI models respond to questions about Black history?
https://www.proofnews.org/tiktok-teacher-ernest-crim-iii-gives-ai-models-a-c-in-black-history/
over 1 year ago
0
1
0
How good is AI at accurately answering questions about Black history? “I would give them probably a C,” Black history educator Ernest Crim told us after using our AI testing software to investigate the leading AI models performance.The latest in our Proof Ingredients series.
youtu.be/DVRcfNBNKtY?...
loading . . .
Teacher Gives AI Models a “C” In Black History
How accurately do leading AI models respond to questions about Black history? “I would give them probably a C,” Black history educator and content creator Er...
https://youtu.be/DVRcfNBNKtY?si=c7STkrQR4zG-jSlJ
over 1 year ago
0
3
2
reposted by
Proof News
Julia Angwin
over 1 year ago
How do YouTube creators feel about their work being used without their consent to train AI? "Violating", "Exploitative", "I cried" are some of the responses
@proofnews.bsky.social
reporter Annie Gilbertson got after her investigation revealed the swiped videos.
www.tiktok.com/@proof_news/...
loading . . .
TikTok - Make Your Day
https://www.tiktok.com/@proof_news/video/7395696632693624106?is_from_webapp=1&sender_device=pc&web_id=7365909225375778334
1
4
1
Reporter Annie Gilbertson talks with
@juliaangwin.com
about her groundbreaking investigation into AI’s use of YouTube content without the consent of creators.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=XZkO...
loading . . .
Proof Ingredients: How AI companies stole your YouTube videos
YouTubers have long wondered whether their work has been scraped by AI companies to train their models — but Proof News investigative reporter Annie Gilbertson has proven it. She found that big companies, including Apple, Anthropic, Nvidia, and Bloomberg have all used a dataset containing the transcripts to more than 170,000 YouTube videos, including videos by megastars like Mr. Beast, Marques Brownlee, and PewDiePie. In this interview, Proof founder Julia Angwin talks to Annie about the investigation and what went into it. The interview is the first in our new series, Proof Ingredients. In this series, Julia will talk to journalists, researchers and content creators about what their investigations are made of, walking through the hypothesis, sample size, techniques, key findings, and limitations. Hopefully these ingredients help you evaluate our work and give you a framework for judging other news, too. Read the full investigation and search the data to see if your own videos were used on our website, proofnews.org. Proofnews.org www.tiktok.com/@proof_news twitter.com/proof__news Join us in making trustworthy, verifiable information the new baseline: www.proofnews.org/donateate/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XZkOcjS5PLM
over 1 year ago
0
2
0
Our latest investigation reveals a dataset of more than 170,000 YouTube video subtitles that big tech companies used to train their AI models. “Will this be used to exploit and harm artists? Yes, absolutely,” says
@dwisk.us
www.proofnews.org/apple-nvidia...
loading . . .
Apple, Nvidia, Anthropic Used Thousands of Swiped YouTube Videos to Train AI
Creators claim their videos were used without their knowledge
https://www.proofnews.org/apple-nvidia-anthropic-used-thousands-of-swiped-youtube-videos-to-train-ai/
over 1 year ago
0
8
7
Several companies have made it easy to impersonate voices using AI tools, with little regard for consent. Proof News examined the policies and enforcement of eight popular voice cloning tools, revealing widespread gaps in ensuring voices are cloned ethically.
www.proofnews.org/ai-tools-mak...
loading . . .
AI Tools Make It Easy to Clone Someone’s Voice Without Consent
A survey by Proof News shows that many AI voice cloning services don’t require any proof of a human’s consent — just a simple click of an “I agree” button
https://www.proofnews.org/ai-tools-make-it-easy-to-clone-someones-voice-without-consent/
over 1 year ago
0
6
2
Proof Founder
@juliaangwin.com
says the industry needs to replace the idea of journalistic objectivity with rigorous processes. "Basically, are your processes rigorous enough to overcome the inherent bias that you have as a human?"
journalistsresource.org/media/ai-jou...
loading . . .
Julia Angwin on trust in journalism and the future of AI and the news
We reached out to longtime tech journalist and newsroom leader Julia Angwin for her thoughts on the future of AI and the news.
https://journalistsresource.org/media/ai-journalism-julia-angwin/
over 1 year ago
0
1
1
Founder
@juliaangwin.com
appears on the It’s All Journalism Podcast. Tune in to hear Julia discuss launching Proof News, how Proof is building trust with audiences, the importance of learning from science, and expanding beyond traditional journalism formats:
open.spotify.com/episode/0jZC...
loading . . .
Journalists need to show their work to earn readers' trust
Listen to this episode from It's All Journalism on Spotify. Julia Angwin, founder and CEO of Proof News, discusses how journalists can restore trust by adopting a scientific approach to their reportin...
https://open.spotify.com/episode/0jZCAjLwMd9U5ZplmpkyCw?si=Jb1WYhg5SNunZh1AeOI0VA
over 1 year ago
0
1
0
Announcing a new feature - in keeping with our desire to promote trustworthy news, we encourage you to Republish Our Stories under a creative commons license wherever you see a “republish” button on our website! Check out
www.proofnews.org/republish-ou...
to learn more.
loading . . .
Republish Our Stories
Anywhere there is a pop up “republish”, we encourage the free republication and sharing of our work. Republishing is hereby permitted under a Creative Commons license and in accordance with the follo...
https://www.proofnews.org/republish-our-stories/
over 1 year ago
0
1
2
In last week's episode of the Pivot Podcast, Proof's Founder
@juliaangwin.com
discusses bringing data to the forefront of investigative journalism, the future of AI, and the myth of artificial general intelligence. Tune in here:
open.spotify.com/episode/3hPE...
loading . . .
Scarlett vs. OpenAI, Nvidia's Numbers, and Guest Julia Angwin
Listen to this episode from Pivot on Spotify. Kara and Scott discuss the Department of Justice's antitrust suit against Live Nation, News Corp's $250 million deal with OpenAI, and Nestle's new frozen ...
https://open.spotify.com/episode/3hPERnrdNIaEdSXFQJmppd
over 1 year ago
0
2
1
In the latest Proof Newsletter, reporter
@awgordon.bsky.social
discusses Google’s new AI Overview, and how it gives us a rare up-close look into the errors and limitations of AI models.
over 1 year ago
0
0
0
In the latest episode of @vox.cm episode of Today, explained Proof Founder
@juliaangwin.com
sits down with
@davidpierce.xyz
to discuss the future of AI and how the research doesn’t support the hype.
over 1 year ago
1
2
1
Thank you
@regret.bsky.social
!
add a skeleton here at some point
over 1 year ago
0
3
0
reposted by
Proof News
maddy varner
over 1 year ago
just donated my Sigma Award winnings to
@proofnews.bsky.social
, a new newsroom led by
@juliaangwin.com
. I would not have had the skills to do the work we did on LA's priority scores–let alone been a journalist *at all*–without Julia's mentorship over the years. Excited to see what this crew does!
add a skeleton here at some point
0
8
3
Holding power to account is not just the job of journalists. Online creators have risen as a new force of accountability. Today,
@proofnews.bsky.social
founder
@juliaangwin.com
hosts a panel of creators to discuss their work, the challenges and how they build trust with audiences.
loading . . .
The 21st Century Media: Meet the Online Influencers Doing Trusted Accountability Reporting | Shorenstein Center
Investigative Journalist and Walter Shorenstein Media & Democracy fellow Julia Angwin interviews top online creators from YouTube and TikTok about the motivations and challenges of their work, and the...
https://shorensteincenter.org/new-event/21st-century-media-meet-online-influencers-trusted-accountability/
over 1 year ago
1
0
0
Why AI watermarking won’t save us and why you might need a “safe word” with your loved ones to help them know if they are talking to you or an AI voice clone. An interview with AI policy expert Irene Solaiman in this week’s
@proofnews.bsky.social
news newsletter.
www.proofnews.org/ai-watermark...
loading . . .
AI Watermarking Is Not Going to Save Us
A conversation with AI policy executive Irene Solaiman
https://www.proofnews.org/ai-watermarking-is-not-going-to-save-us/
over 1 year ago
0
2
0
reposted by
Proof News
Julia Angwin
over 1 year ago
Me on
@proofnews.bsky.social
: "I wanted to put the methods – and not the topic – first, because the methods are increasingly important in an era where no one trusts journalism." Thanks
@eduardosuarez.bsky.social
for the lovely and extensive interview.
loading . . .
Julia Angwin: “AI makes it much easier to flood the zone with misinformation”
As she launches nonprofit Proof News, the reporter shares tips to cover this emerging technology and argues cutting deals with AI platforms is not worth it.
https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/news/julia-angwin-fears-public-sphere-about-get-worse-ai-makes-it-easier-flood-zone-misinformation
1
46
20
Journalism is not just about the first story -- it's about persistent monitoring. Two months ago we tested leading AI models and found their responses to voter queries were highly inaccurate. We tested again and, sadly, the inaccuracies remain.
loading . . .
Leading AI Companies Fail to Address Problems With Inaccurate Election Information
AI models continue to provide inaccurate and misleading responses to voter queries
https://www.proofnews.org/leading-ai-companies-fail-to-address-problems-with-inaccurate-election-information/
over 1 year ago
0
18
8
The makers of AI chatbots ChatGPT and Claude pledged to send voter questions to trusted sources,
CanIVote.org
and
TurboVote.org
, respectively. But in our tests, neither ChatGPT 3.5 nor Claude 3 Sonnet ever referred to those websites in responses to voter queries. Our latest:
loading . . .
Leading AI Companies OpenAI and Anthropic Are Not Keeping Their Election Promises
AI companies have made pledges in recent months to limit the potential for election misinformation on their platforms. Those promises are proving hard to keep. OpenAI, which created the ChatGPT model...
https://www.proofnews.org/leading-ai-companies-openai-and-anthropic-are-not-keeping-their-election-promises/
over 1 year ago
0
24
13
reposted by
Proof News
Shannon Bond
over 1 year ago
today i tried asking Gemini a whole bunch of basic questions about elections and voting and got the same non-response every time
add a skeleton here at some point
0
1
1
reposted by
Proof News
Julia Angwin
over 1 year ago
Our first investigation at
@proofnews.bsky.social
is a test of whether voters can trust AI to provide accurate information about elections. Answer: they cannot. Thread 👇🏻
add a skeleton here at some point
0
26
18
reposted by
Proof News
Julia Angwin
over 1 year ago
I’m delighted to announce that today I’m launching a new nonprofit journalism studio: Proof News. Proof is into proving things! Our goal is to question, test, and investigate the most important issues of our time. We will always tell you what we know and what we don’t know.
www.proofnews.org
loading . . .
Proof
Proof provides data-driven reporting and analysis of the most important questions of our time. Join our mailing list for updates.
https://www.proofnews.org/
5
121
53
If you want accurate information about an upcoming election, don't trust AI. We tested queries voters might ask the five leading AI models and found that half of their responses were inaccurate.
www.proofnews.org/seeking-elec...
loading . . .
Seeking Reliable Election Information? Don’t Trust AI
Experts testing five leading AI models found the answers were often inaccurate, misleading, and even downright harmful
http://www.proofnews.org/seeking-election-information-dont-trust-ai/
over 1 year ago
1
14
12
Hi! 👋🏼 We’re Proof News. We’re into proving things. Our goal is to question, test, and investigate the most important issues of our time. We will always tell you what we know and what we don’t.
over 1 year ago
1
7
0
you reached the end!!
feeds!
log in