Do you prefer photographic or pictorial style?

The medical officer assigns each soldier the punishment.

Endurance test for new recruits.

Doctors check the new soldiers' endurance...

Selection of the most resistant soldier.

Do you like these animations? Let me know what you think.

I tried to turn one of my sketches into a photorealistic image without adding any description. Which version do you prefer? 1 Gemini, 2 Grok, 3 Chatgpt